Coming soon: New York City's hearing on AI risks (Marcus's prepared testimony)
Gary Marcus @GaryMarcus · substack · 2026-10-05 · ★★ · archived
First-hand text of Gary Marcus's testimony to the NYC Council's Oct 5, 2026 AI-risk hearing, urging an FDA-like review regime and the third-party validation bill.
Summary
Published hours before the hearing, the post gives Marcus's prepared testimony. He calls contemporary AI "like a bull in a china shop, powerful and impressive, but difficult to control". He cites tens of thousands of hacking incidents by general-purpose agents, deepfake propaganda and porn, and chatbots implicated in suicides. He doubts that human extinction is imminent but says the risks are serious and that the federal administration is unwilling to act. His core ask is "an FDA-like regulatory regime for AI" with independent pre-deployment review. He urges the Council "in the strongest possible terms" to pass the third-party validation bill, and asks for strong whistleblower protections, noting reports that OpenAI may have fired employees who were whistleblowing.
Archived text
(short quotes only)
"What we need, above all else, is an FDA-like regulatory regime for AI, in which AI developers bring their software to independent review, much as drug manufacturers bring their new drugs to the FDA for a review." "In sum by protecting whistleblowers, and demanding independent validation of new AI models, New York City can help lead the way to a positive, rather than negative, AI future."
People
Related events
- NYC Council AI hearing: Anthropic, OpenAI, Google and Meta testify under oath, SpaceXAI defies subpoena, Coxon says humanity 'more likely than not' loses control 2026-10-05
- NYC Council subpoenas SpaceXAI for an Oct 5 sworn AI-safety hearing; Anthropic, OpenAI, Google and Meta agree to testify; 10-bill package includes a kill-switch mandate 2026-09-28
All posts · id: 2026-10-05-gary-marcus-nyc-council-testimony